Image Source: Pexels
What central banks can learn from a wild week in markets?
Life comes at you fast if you’re a central banker; think Noah Lyles in the Olympics’ 100-metre final. Talk of emergency rate cuts, 50 basis point moves, and an imminent US recession? None of that was presumably on the Fed’s bingo card at its July policy meeting just nine days ago. Has Jerome Powell been caught in the blocks? The Fed Chair has, of course, seen his fair share of market turmoil. And I suspect the mood in Fed Towers is not one of panic. A rogue US jobs market may have been the catalyst for what’s unfolded in financial markets, but what’s followed says as much about crowded positioning and low summer liquidity as it does about genuine macro fears.Higher volatility isn’t necessarily a concern for the central bankers unless it exposes pockets of leverage that prompt a doom loop of issues in the financial system. So far that doesn’t seem to be happening. And even if it did, policymakers are adept at creating bespoke schemes to contain fires as and when they emerge.That’s all well and good, but it doesn’t mean there aren’t lessons for the central banks from this week’s shenanigans. And here are four reasons why officials should avoid becoming complacent:Firstly, it’s not obvious that the current bout of instability is fully behind us. Our Rates Strategy team describes the Treasury market as “rudderless”.Investors are hungrier than ever for clarity on the US macro story, but the reality is they’ve been trading in a void of information. Data like jobless claims, a number that frankly is nothing more than noise in the short term, has attracted far more attention than it deserves.That means Powell’s appearance at the Fed’s Jackson Hole conference in a couple of weeks will be pivotal. And it also means that next week’s US inflation data is going to attract even more eyeballs than usual. The story has been much better recently, and with the jobs market on the turn, the Fed is telling us that it is inclined to put less focus on its inflation mandate than it was just a few months ago.But here’s the thing: the data has a habit of ignoring “the narrative”. An upside upset on inflation isn’t our base case, but our US expert James Knightley warns that it is possible.Second, there’s the jobs market itself. At least some of the bonkers market moves can be traced back to the triggering of the “Sahm rule”, which shows that recession has always ensued when the three-month moving average of the unemployment rate goes half a percent above its low in the prior 12 months. And as of last Friday’s data, that’s now the case.Powell argues that much of this is explained by a rise in worker supply as opposed to increased layoffs. James K agrees, but more importantly, he warns that the situation can change quickly. The Fed’s Christopher Waller has said in the past that a rise in joblessness could become more apparent once the vacancy rate falls back below pre-Covid levels. And we’re very close to that point right now. Slow rises in the unemployment rate have a habit of turning more rapid as the economy flirts with recession.Third, officials should be wary of drawing too many conclusions from other macro data that, for now at least, looks perfectly OK. The healthy rebound in the services ISM index this week is a good example. But take a look at previous recessions, and you’ll find that the more serious slowdown in GDP growth and consumer spending tends to come after and not before the Sahm rule has been triggered – see the charts below. James K has, for some time now, been highlighting the mounting stress among US consumers, particularly at the lower end of the income scale.Remember, too, that the recent strength in US activity is in no small part because interest rate hikes have hit the economy much more slowly than they did in the past. That’s down to long-dated mortgage fixes and more prevalent interest rate hedging at American corporations.So here’s my fourth point: if the economy is more insulated from rate hikes, then exactly the same is true of rate cuts. If the jobs market really does start to weaken, then there’s not a huge amount the Fed can do about it in the short term.That’s a lot to think about over in Washington, so let me leave you with our latest ING forecasts, which are out today.James Knightley now forecasts a 50 basis point rate cut from the Fed in September, and he thinks that could easily happen again later in the year. For now, he’s projecting 100 basis points of cuts in total for the remainder of this year and another 100 next year.After months of just sitting in the stands, the race is now on for Mr Powell.
Chart of the week: Weaker growth and spending tends to come after, not before, the Sahm rule is triggered
*Based on Sahm rule triggers points in 1980, 1981, 1990, 2001 and 2008. 2020 excluded given it wasn’t a typical recession.
Source: Macrobond, ING calculations
THINK Ahead for Developed Markets
United States (James Knightley)
United Kingdom (James Smith)
Norway (James Smith)
THINK Ahead for Central and Eastern Europe
Poland (Adam Antoniak)
Czech Republic (David Havrlant)
Key events in developed markets next week
Source: Refinitiv, ING
Key events in EMEA next week
Source: Refinitiv, INGMore By This Author:Asia Week Ahead: China’s Economic Data, Japan’s GDP And India’s CPI And Trade Figures Gold Monthly: Rally Might Not Be Over Just Yet China’s CPI Inflation Rebounded Due To A Smaller Drag From Food Prices